← All summaries

Do Valuations Still Matter?

Ask The Compound · Ben Carlson, Duncan Hill · April 29, 2026 · Original

Most important take away

Valuation metrics like the Shiller CAPE ratio have been above their long-term average roughly 95% of the time since 1990, yet the market has compounded near 11% annually — meaning valuations should set expectations, not be used to time the market. Diversification (international, small/mid caps), behavioral discipline, and matching the right product (bond ladders vs. total bond funds) to your specific goal matter far more than chasing a “fair” valuation level.

Summary

This episode delivers actionable insights across diversification, valuation, behavioral finance, fees, and bond strategy.

Stocks/ETFs mentioned:

  • Microsoft, Netflix, Meta, Robinhood, Coinbase, Block, Blackstone — Ben previously called these “safe bottom-fish” picks; most have rallied (Netflix being the laggard). Not an explicit recommendation, but a reminder that quality names beaten down can recover.
  • Vanguard Total Stock Market Index (VTI) and Vanguard Total World (VT) — used as benchmarks for diversification math.
  • Nvidia — cited as the classic example of a “ridiculously priced” stock that crushed valuation skeptics for a decade.
  • BND (Vanguard Total Bond) — perpetual bond fund, no maturity date.
  • TLT (long-duration Treasuries) — Duncan lost money here; warning about long-duration interest rate risk.
  • iShares iBonds, State Street, Invesco target-maturity bond ETFs — recommended for building bond ladders or saving for a known future expense (down payment, tuition, wedding).
  • I-Bonds (TreasuryDirect) — Duncan’s one bond win.

Actionable insights:

  1. Diversification: S&P 500 + EAFE/developed-ex-US gives you ~75% of the global market cap; you’re “probably okay” without small/mid/emerging, but you give up roughly 25% of the global pie that sometimes outperforms. Decide if you’re comfortable owning only the top of the cap stack.
  2. CAPE ratio: Don’t use it as a line in the sand. Long-term average (17.7x) is dragged down by 1870s data. 10-year average is 32x. Stocks have been “overvalued” for 15+ years. Use valuations to set return expectations, not to time entry/exit.
  3. Financial anxiety at high net worth ($5M+): Stop opening the spreadsheet weekly — once every 6 months is enough. Define what the money is for (don’t say “freedom” or “travel”). Identify guilt-free spending zones. Read Die With Zero by Bill Perkins. Listen to Ramit Sethi’s Money for Couples. Consider talking to a financial advisor as a “financial therapist.”
  4. 1% advisory fee on $1.2M ($12K/year): If you’re only getting investment management with little activity and no planning/tax/insurance work, demand they justify the fee or move to a robo-advisor or low-cost ETF portfolio.
  5. Bond ladders vs. bond funds: For a known future cash need (3, 5, 7 years out), use target-maturity bond ETFs (iShares iBonds, etc.) — they mature at par and remove duration/interest-rate risk near maturity. Use BND/AGG for general fixed-income exposure where you want recession hedge benefits. Avoid TLT unless you specifically want 30-year duration.

Chapter Summaries

Intro & stock-pick check-in: Ben revisits prior bottom-fishing calls (MSFT, NFLX, META, HOOD, COIN, SQ, BX) — most worked out, only Netflix lagged.

Q1 — Geographic and cap-size diversification: Developed-markets-only and S&P-500-only investing covers ~75% of the global market. You’re giving up ~7.5% emerging markets and ~17% US small/mid/micro. Reasonable choice but acknowledges you’ll miss rotations.

Q2 — Is the CAPE ratio still relevant?: Currently 36.5x vs. long-term average of 17.7x. Market has been above average 95% of the time since 1990, returning ~11%/year. Even Shiller himself has walked back the indicator. Use for expectations, not market timing.

Q3 — Self-constructed financial prison ($5M, 8 years to retirement): Anxiety is emotional, not numeric. Stop checking spreadsheets. Define your “perfect Thursday.” Identify guilt-free spending. Recommended: Die With Zero (Bill Perkins) and Ramit Sethi’s Money for Couples podcast. Consider a financial advisor as third-party therapist.

Q4 — 1% fee on $1.2M actively managed account: Likely overpaying for what sounds like a programmatic, low-touch portfolio. Request fee justification; if no planning services or alpha, switch to lower-cost robo or ETF portfolio.

Q5 — Bond ladders vs. BND: Target-maturity bond ETFs (iShares iBonds family) work like individual bonds — mature at par on a target date. Good for known future expenses or building a ladder to neutralize interest-rate risk. BND is perpetual and useful for general exposure but exposes you to duration loss (as in 2022). Money market funds and T-bills have minimal volatility because of short duration; long-dated TLT is the opposite.