How Do You Protect Against a Bear Market?
Most important take away
A diversified 60/40 portfolio still works as a bear-market shock absorber, but bond investors must now diversify across TIPS, T-bills, short/intermediate corporates and treasuries to handle inflation risk. Consumers remain financially healthy with enormous home equity and credit headroom, so the market likely keeps grinding higher until job losses meaningfully tick up.
Summary
Actionable insights and investment advice from the episode:
- 60/40 still works as a shock absorber. Going back to the late 1920s, in years when the S&P 500 fell, 10-year Treasuries fell in the same year only 4 times. On average during equity down years, bonds returned roughly +4% versus stocks at roughly -13.5% — about 18 percentage points of relative cushion. Action: don’t abandon bonds just because of the 2022 drawdown.
- Diversify the bond sleeve. The 2022 bond bear market taught investors that the real risk to bonds is inflation (which drags rates higher), not just rates themselves. Action: build a fixed income allocation across TIPS, T-bills, short and intermediate corporates, and Treasuries rather than relying solely on long-duration bonds.
- Be intentional about gold/precious metals. Ben notes a 2% sleeve won’t move the needle. Gold’s long-run returns have historically been closer to bonds than to stocks, but with much higher volatility. Gold was dead money through the 1980s and 1990s. Action: if you add gold/precious metals as a hedge, size it large enough to matter, and treat it as a “risk-off” diversifier rather than a stock substitute.
- Stop trying to time it. Markets move daily because investors are emotional and have wildly different time horizons (HFT firms, hedge funds, pensions, retirees de-risking, baby boomers spending down). Robert Shiller’s work showed prices are far more volatile than underlying cash flows. Action: dollar-cost average and hold; volatility is the price you pay for long-term equity returns — if it weren’t volatile, returns wouldn’t be high.
- Consumer is still strong; no canary yet. JP Morgan Guide to the Markets shows household assets ~$205T versus liabilities ~$21T. Total household debt of ~$19T sounds large but is small relative to assets. Credit card balances are ~$1.3T but only ~30% of available credit limits are used (in line with the 25-year average). There is ~$35T of home equity (up from ~$18T at end of 2019). Foreclosures and bankruptcies are still near historic lows. 90+ day delinquencies are creeping up in autos and credit cards, and student loan delinquencies jumped because COVID forbearance ended. Net worth has grown fastest in percentage terms for the bottom 50% (+130% since end of 2019). Implication: spending continues until people start losing jobs en masse — watch unemployment and layoffs (especially in software/AI-exposed firms) as the real trigger.
- Be very cautious with private investments / alternatives. Manager dispersion is enormous: David Swensen’s Yale data shows top vs. bottom quartile dispersion is small in stocks and bonds but massive in real assets, leveraged buyouts/private equity, and venture capital. Bottom-quartile alts can devastate returns. Liquidity risk is the biggest hidden danger — Ben tells a story of a credit fund that took 5 years to return capital after a large redemption, and a client whose private investment ultimately returned zero. Action for advisors: don’t try to DIY manager selection; use platforms designed to help with sourcing and due diligence, and set very clear liquidity and return expectations with clients. The Blue Owl CEO is quoted admitting the private credit industry “could have done a better job” explaining dynamics to advisors and clients. Interval funds help but don’t eliminate liquidity risk.
- Personal finance lessons. Indexing the whole market is the right default for ~95% of people. Don’t be so frugal you ruin your life — Ben has seen many wealth-management clients save their whole lives only to fall ill or die before they can spend it. Be “selectively cheap”: cut spending on things that don’t matter to you so you can spend on things that do (Ben’s example: he and his wife skip luxury cars/furniture/expensive dinners but spend on travel and kids). Most clients eventually realize they came for portfolio management but actually need full financial planning — insurance, estate, tax, and a spending plan. Worry about money never goes away no matter the wealth level; it just changes shape.
Specific stocks/companies mentioned:
- Vanguard (
$12T AUM) and BlackRock ($14T AUM) — cited as evidence that much investor behavior has been institutionalized, yet markets still move violently. - SPY (SPDR S&P 500 ETF) — first US ETF; passive vehicle but turns over roughly every 13 days, illustrating how passively-built products are actively traded.
- Block (formerly Square) — Jack Dorsey’s company; mentioned as having laid off ~40% of staff with the stock down ~60%, used as an example of how AI-driven layoffs at high-paying employers could become the catalyst that finally slows consumer spending.
- Public (sponsor) — investing platform with AI-generated index/portfolio capability.
No specific buy/sell recommendations on individual securities were given.
Chapter Summaries
1. Intro and housekeeping. Ben broadcasts from a WeWork in Washington DC after his hotel wasn’t ready. Thanks Bill Sweeney for filling in last week. Plugs his upcoming book (May 12 release, available for pre-order). Sponsor read for Public’s AI-generated index feature.
2. Can a 60/40 protect against a bear market? (Charles, age 70s, $1M portfolio). Ben argues yes — historical data shows bonds rarely fall alongside stocks and on average cushion the portfolio by ~18 percentage points in equity down years. But the bond sleeve must now be diversified across TIPS, T-bills, and various maturities/credits because inflation is the real bond risk. Discussion of whether gold should be reframed as part of the “risk-off” allocation alongside bonds; Ben says it can make sense from a portfolio-management standpoint but gold’s volatility complicates the comparison.
3. Why do markets move so much short term if they go up long term? (Megan). Because investors are emotional and have heterogeneous time horizons and goals. Ben cites Shiller’s finding that prices swing far more than underlying dividends/earnings justify. Volatility is the cost of higher long-term returns — if returns were smooth, they’d be risk-free and small. Duncan adds that not all selling is panic: boomers de-risking and spending in retirement is also a structural source of selling.
4. How is the consumer doing? (Mike on Twitter). Walks through JP Morgan Guide to the Markets and NY Fed Household Debt and Credit Report charts. Aggregate balance sheet is very strong: $205T assets vs $21T liabilities, $35T home equity (nearly double 2019), credit card utilization only ~30%. Delinquencies are rising modestly in autos and credit cards; student loan delinquencies are catching up post-COVID. Foreclosures and bankruptcies remain near historic lows. Bottom 50% net worth is up 130% since end of 2019. Conclusion: nothing stops the consumer until job losses become personal; AI-driven layoffs at firms like Block could eventually be the trigger.
5. Should advisors use private investments / alternatives? (Anonymous young advisor). Ben says no, you’re not failing your clients by sticking to ETFs and mutual funds. Private markets carry a myth of sophistication, but Swensen data shows top-vs-bottom-quartile manager dispersion is enormous in PE, VC, and real assets — being in the wrong manager is catastrophic, unlike in public stocks. Liquidity risk is the killer; he shares anecdotes of multi-year lockups and total losses. If an advisor pursues alts, use a dedicated platform for sourcing and manager selection and set explicit expectations with clients. Cites the Blue Owl CEO admitting the private credit industry mishandled communication.
6. Personal finance lessons from working in wealth management (Dave). Duncan: indexing the whole market is the boring-but-right default; don’t pinch every penny — money is for living. Ben: agrees, says he was overly frugal early in his marriage; has seen too many clients work their whole lives and never get to spend their wealth. Most clients ultimately need financial planning (insurance, estate, taxes, spending plan), not just portfolio management. “Be selectively cheap” — cut where you don’t care, spend where you do. Worry about money never goes away, it just changes shape.
7. Wrap-up. Thanks to Bill Sweeney for filing Ben’s taxes the night before, and to live viewers. Standard disclaimers.