Smooth Investing When the Ride is Bumpy
Most important take away
Stock market volatility is the normal price of admission for long-term returns, not a signal to panic. The S&P 500 historically drops about 14% intra-year on average, and no bear market has ever failed to recover. The single most important action during downturns is to not panic-sell, and ideally to continue buying quality companies at a discount.
Summary
The episode is a full mailbag segment responding to listener Brandon O’Shaughnessy’s question about surviving 2026’s market volatility through diversification and long-term investing.
Actionable insights and investment advice:
- Volatility is normal, not an emergency. The S&P 500 experiences ~14% average intra-year drawdowns, ~5% pullbacks every few months, and ~10% corrections roughly once a year. Understanding this prevents emotional selling.
- Do not panic-sell during downturns. Matt Frankl’s portfolio dropped 60% in 2008-2009. His biggest saving grace was simply not selling. Stocks he bought during that crash (Bank of America, Berkshire Hathaway) went on to produce 500%+ returns.
- Continue investing during downturns. Frankl’s portfolio recovered to new highs in roughly two years partly because he kept putting money in. Without continued investment, recovery would have taken until ~2013.
- Sector rotation is happening now. Energy is up 35% YTD. Utilities and consumer staples are each up ~10%. Tech and financials are down significantly. The S&P 500 is down only ~4%, but tech-heavy or financial-heavy portfolios are down 10-14%.
- Diversification is not “de-worsification.” Even Berkshire Hathaway holds 40-50 stocks at any given time. True diversification means owning many stocks across sectors you understand, while still concentrating in your highest-conviction positions.
- No one can predict the market’s short-term direction. Both analysts agree the market will likely be higher in five years. Frankl made a bold (but uncertain) prediction that the Iran conflict could resolve within a month, triggering a rebound.
Stocks and investments mentioned:
- Prologis (PLD) — Matt Frankl’s top pick if the market drops further. Largest logistics REIT, owns warehouses leased to Amazon and others, top-rated credit, entering the data center space as a “sneaky AI play.” Has rebounded recently but would be attractive on further dips.
- Johnson & Johnson (JNJ) — Rachel Warren’s portfolio stabilizer. Up ~20% YTD and 50% over the past year. Strong immunology, oncology, neuroscience, and med-tech businesses with dozens of billion-dollar platforms.
- PepsiCo (PEP) — John Quas’s pick to improve dividend diversification. A Dividend King (50+ years of dividend increases) with resilient beverage and snack businesses.
- Berkshire Hathaway — Frankl’s perennial favorite, one of his largest positions, consistently added to on dips.
- Bank of America — Bought during the 2008-2009 crisis, returned ~500% since then.
- Mag 7 ETF — Mentioned as down double digits YTD, illustrating that even top-quality companies can underperform in the short term.
Chapter Summaries
Chapter 1: Understanding Volatility
The team introduces Brandon’s listener question about surviving 2026 market volatility. Rachel Warren defines volatility as the speed and frequency of price changes — like turbulence on a flight. She explains that the S&P 500 averages a 14% intra-year drawdown, with 5% pullbacks every few months and 10% corrections roughly once a year. Volatility is the price of admission for higher long-term returns, not a reason to exit.
Chapter 2: Living Through a Real Crash
Matt Frankl shares his experience investing through the 2008-2009 financial crisis, where his portfolio lost 60% (the S&P dropped 55%). Recovery took about two years with continued investing, but would have taken until ~2013 without it. His key lesson: not panicking was his biggest saving grace. He bought Bank of America and Berkshire Hathaway at distressed prices, both of which became massive long-term winners.
Chapter 3: The 2026 Market Outlook
The S&P 500 is down ~4% YTD as of taping. Software and tech stocks have been hit hardest. The Iran conflict is a key risk factor, with potential second-order effects through higher energy prices and grocery inflation. Both analysts agree the market will almost certainly be higher in five years. Frankl offers a bold prediction that the Iran conflict may resolve within a month, but cautions against betting on it.
Chapter 4: Sector Performance and Portfolio Impact
Energy is up 35% YTD, utilities and consumer staples up ~10%. Tech and financials are the worst-performing sectors. The hosts note that individual portfolio performance varies greatly depending on sector concentration. A “sea of red” portfolio likely indicates heavy tech or financial exposure, not poor stock-picking. Current sector rotation is a normal part of market cycles.
Chapter 5: The Case for Diversification
The team argues that concentration may build wealth in rare cases but is more akin to high-stakes gambling. Diversification allows investors to stay in the market long enough for compounding to work. They address Charlie Munger’s “de-worsification” critique, clarifying that Munger opposed owning stocks in sectors you don’t understand — not owning many stocks. Even Berkshire holds 40-50 stocks while concentrating in its highest-conviction positions.
Chapter 6: Stocks to Watch in a Downturn
Matt Frankl highlights Prologis (PLD) as his top pick if the market drops further — a dominant logistics REIT with data center expansion. Rachel Warren points to Johnson & Johnson (JNJ) as her portfolio stabilizer, up 20% YTD with strong fundamentals. John Quas identifies PepsiCo (PEP) as a dividend-focused diversifier he wants to add. The hosts close by inviting listener questions at [email protected].